Pros And Cons Of Genetic Engineering Humans
Other human genetic engineering pros and cons include the desirable characteristics in different plants and animals at the same time convenient. One can also do the manipulation of genes in trees or big plants. This will enable the trees to absorb increased amount of carbon dioxide, and it will reduce the effects of global warming. Pros and Cons In the table below you will find some of the important advantages and disadvantages of genetic engineering. You will realize that each benefit has a negative aspect. Basically, by modifying the genes, we can improve a condition at the cost of another. This article helps explain what GMOs are, provides a balanced explanation of their pros and cons,. Modified using genetic engineering technology. Free Essay: Modern society is on the verge of a biotechnological revolution: the foods we eat no longer serve simply to feed us, but to feed entire nations.
List of the Pros of Genetic Engineering 1. It can improve the nutrition, taste, and growth rate of crops. Crops like tomatoes, soy beans, rice, and potatoes are currently going through the genetic engineering process as a way to obtain additional strains that provide better nutritional qualities and increase yields.
Every living creature contains more than 100, 000 genes, which are the units in chromosomes controlling heredity. The genes are made of DNA, the hereditary material (the 'building bricks'), which contains the genetic code of a living being; it is by this material that its cellular structure is defined.
Many people have inherited diseases because of a defect in just one of their genes. In Britain, for example, about one in 500 people suffers from a hereditary form of heart disease. Some of their children can be helped by gene replacement therapy, by gene transplants before birth (defective genes are replaced by sound ones). Human gene transplants may soon be a common practice in laboratories.
Genetic engineering is a new science. It poses incalculable risks and many moral and ethical questions (for example, the artificial creation and cloning of human beings). On the other hand, it can be beneficial to modern medicine: certain diseases which cause misery, pain and distress to both children and parents can be eradicated in this way.
EXAMPLES OF APPLIED GENETIC ENGINEERING:
1. Genetically engineered sheep produce human proteins used to combat blood diseases, for example haemophilia B. The researchers inject human genes, which code the factor-VIII protein, into the fertilized eggs of sheep so that the protein will finally emerge in the animals' milk, from which it must be isolated.
2. Scientists have found a way of correcting a hereditary defect which causes a severe form of heart disease (people who inherit this disease suffer from high cholesterol levels). They have inserted a gene that controls body cholesterol levels into liver cells, using a specially created virus. So far this technique has worked in rabbit cells.
GENETICISTS' ARGUMENTS IN FAVOUR OF GENETIC ENGINEERING:
1. By producing hybrids of plants (for example hybrid wheat) or animals (half sheep, half goat) they can help farmers worldwide: grain grows faster and is made resistant to insects and disease; animals are more productive, need less food etc.
2. Hybrid animals can produce drugs and help modern medicine in its search for new products to combat blood diseases etc.
3. By modifying an embryo's structure at an early stage genetics can exclude some genetic risks.
4. The discovery of a defective gene need not necessarily raise the option of abortion: preventive treatment may suffice.
MORAL AND ETHICAL QUESTIONS RAISED BY GENETIC ENGINEERING:
1. The dignity of the unborn child, its uniqueness, must be respected: the embryo's life ought to be protected from the moment of fertilization on.
2. Should certain types of experimentation on embryos be allowed in spite of the danger of human beings being regarded as laboratory material?
3. Should an embryo be aborted if it has a defective gene which has been discovered prenatally?
4. Scientists may attempt to produce a super-species of human beings: they may use gene transplants to enhance physical appearance, talents or intelligence, which could give rise to the danger of genetic manipulation.
Exercise 1.Discuss in groups “Genetic Engineering: pros and cons”.
Exercise 2. Imagine that before you were born your parents had 'designed' you. lf you had been them, what would you have changed? Think about these questions:
− Which one aspect of your appearance would you change?
− Which one aspect of your character/personality would you change?
− How do you think your life might have been different?
− Are you pleased your parents did not design you or do you wish they had?
Compare your answers in pairs or small groups.
Exercise 3.Read through the article and answer this question: Why do the Jones want a baby girl?
NEW LAWS MAY ALLOW CHOICE OF BABY'S SEX
Jim and Debbie Jones (not their real names), whose daughter was killed in a tragic domestic accident last year, plan to use the new British human rights laws to win the legal right to choose the sex of their baby.
The Jones, who have four sons, say that the 'female dimension' has disappeared from their family since the death of Jasmine. 'Words cannot describe what it feels like to lose the little girl we had wanted for so long. We know another girl won't replace Jasmine, but we want the chance to try,' said Jim Jones. 'What we're hoping to do with the use of technology is create the female dimension again. We have psychologists’ reports and doctors' reports which confirm that our reasons for wanting a girl go beyond just wanting to replace her. Our family doesn't feel complete any more. I adore our sons but we would like another girl.'
Gender selection is only possible in Britain for medical rather than social, psychological or physical reasons. Pro-life campaigners say that if the Jones are allowed to choose the sex of their baby, it could lead to babies becoming consumer items. A spokesman said: 'We are totally opposed to engineering the numbers and genders of people in society. That leads only to disaster.'
The Jones' lawyers will be basing their arguments on new human rights legislation. Article six guarantees everyone a 'fair hearing' from public authorities and Article eight protects the right of everyone to 'respect for family life'.
Exercise 3.1. Read the article again. Mark the following sentences true (T) or false (F):
1. The Jones feel they need a baby girl to make their family complete again.
2. At the moment in Britain it is not possible to choose the sex of your baby.
3. New laws on human rights may allow the Jones to choose the sex of their baby.
Exercise 3.2. Discuss this question in pairs or small groups:
Do you think the Jones should be allowed to choose to have a baby girl? Why? Why not?
Exercise 3.3. Look at these sentences from the article. Notice the expressions with right:
Jim and Debbie Jones plan to win the legal right to choose the sex of their baby.
Article eight protects the right of everyone to 'respect for family life'.
Cross out the word in italics which does not collocate with right:
1. You can have, win, protect, demand, build, defend, challenge the right to choose.
2. It's a(n) legal, moral, straight, automatic, basic right.
Look at the sentences below. Mark them in the following way:
ü if you agree;
x if you disagree;
? if you partly agree and partly disagree.
Pros And Cons Of Genetic Engineering Quizlet
1. An unborn child has rights. Those rights must be protected.
2. We don't have the right to interfere with a child's future personality and appearance.
3. Deciding the sex of your child will be a basic right in fifty years' time.
4. We should have the automatic right to choose particular genes for our own babies.
Compare your answers in pairs or small groups.
Exercise 4.Work in pairs or small groups. In each of the following situations someone is explaining what genetic selection they want to make and why. Decide whether you think they should be allowed to do what they want.
1. There is a history of red hair in my family. I have red hair and I was badly teased at school. I would like to make sure my child does not have red hair.
2. My four-year-old daughter, my only child, has a fatal blood disease. She will die before she is 12 unless we can find a match for
a bone marrow transplant. I want to make sure my next baby is a suitable match for my daughter.
3. In my family there is a history of a fatal disease that affects the nervous system. I want to make sure that my baby is not likely to get this disease.
4. I'm a university professor and my husband is a doctor. We'd like to make sure our baby is intelligent.
5. The male members of my family often suffer from a rare and unpleasant bone disease. I would therefore like to make sure I have a baby girl.
6. I feel there is too much violence and aggression in the world. I would like to make sure my child is a calm and gentle person.
7. I would like to have a very musical or artistic daughter. She should have blonde hair, blue eyes and be about medium height when she grows up.
8. I suffer from a genetic disease which I inherited from my mother. My children have a one in five chance of having the same gene. Before I start a family, I want to have treatment to make sure I do not pass on this gene.
Are you fascinated or horrified by this topic?
GENETIC ENGINEERING:
Genetic engineering is the direct manipulation of a gene of an organism by using bio-technology. This technology is used to change the genetic make-up of cells. New segment or strands of DNA is obtained by either synthesizing DNA in the labs or isolating and copying the required genetic material using recombinant DNA methods.
It is a perfect example where two sciences from different realms namely- biology and engineering merge together to help solve the upcoming problems of this era. It has a plethora of top-notch applications in agriculture, medical sciences, technology and scientific research.
4 STEPS INVOLVED IN GENETIC ENGINEERING:
- DNA Extraction
- Gene cloning and designing
- Transformation
- Backcross Breeding
PROS OF GENETIC ENGINEERING:
- One of the greatest achievements of mankind was the production of artificial insulin. Yes, you heard it right! The first insulin production can be credited to genetic engineering which helped scientists to produce insulin from yeast and E-coli.
- The sudden boom in the field of agriculture to feed the growing population is also a gift of genetic engineering. In 1994, the first genetically synthesized foods were made which became an instant hit. This has helped humans to synthesize hybrid superior quality of seeds artificially.
- The role of genetic engineering has been immense to improve the nutrition value, growth pattern and resilience ability in plants like rice, wheat, potato and tomato. These crops are less likely to be infected from those notorious plant pests.
- Sheep can produce milk which contains therapeutic protein which is believed to cure cystic fibrosis in humans. Thanks to genetic engineering!
- The nematode worms- C. elegans has only a few hundred of cells in its nervous tissue which can provide a substrate to study Alzhimer disease.
- Gene transfer by the help of the viral vectors has been proposed as a means of controlling the invasive species and vaccinating the animals [fauna] from any sort of disease.
- Some organisms can be 'tailor made' with the specific characteristic of absorbing more of carbon dioxide and hence reducing the global warming which is indeed a grave issue human civilization is facing at the present times.
CONS OF GENETIC ENGINEERING:
- Some people are of the notion that it is not right to interfere with nature in our own ways. Who knows it may do us more harm than good.
- Transfer of selected genes from one species to another may lead to the loss in variety. Nature's survival of the fittest will also be harmed. The power of self evolving might be lost which seems potentially more harmful.
- GM crops are more expensive than regular crops and cannot be afforded by the common man of a developing nation.
- It has been found out that some GM crops cause specific allergy to certain people. Pollens in this plants are usually harmful which may harm the insects pollinating them.
Genetic engineering is a breakthrough in human progress which might help us to find the solutions of the questions which pose a grave threat to humanity.